Dual Nature of Man – יצר הרע ויצר טוב

The word the Torah uses to say that God formed Man is וייצר, the letter “yud” appearing twice. As the word יצר can mean inclination or formation, our sages teach us that this verse contains a number of related lessons.

– Man is both mortal and immortal
– Man is both earthly and heavenly
– Man has a good inclination and a bad inclination

When this word is pronounced only one “yud” is heard. Man always appears to have both sides of him but one side is always the more dominant. Which one is up to him. The most holy person is still a person. In the background is his body and his inclinations. He had to fight to be as holy as he is. And even a person who seems to be at the lowest rung of his humanity still contains a spark of holiness within him.

Both inclinations and aspects of Man were created from the very beginning. The God who created Man’s inclination toward the spirit, created Man’s earthly inclinations. There is nothing unholy or wrong with either of Man’s inclinations as long as they are put to use according to God’s instructions. Man was not created to be a מלאך. Man is not pure white. That is God’s realm. That is the realm of angels. Man was created to be אדם. Man is put on earth. whose spiritual side is broken up by his encounter with the physical. Man is “red”. (See this very fundamental concept that RSRH refers to often.

In this world, the world of the senses and with his sensuous nature, Man is to live his life and uplift it all in the service of God. The Christian concept that the sensuous nature of Man comes from Satan is a twisted concept that has been the curse of Man throughout history. (I believe RSRH is saying that by rejecting the body as a part of the service to God, Christianity has missed the main intention of Man’s mission; to uplift his body and this world. By striving to relegate the body as something evil, the body remains unholy or worse. The world does not become transformed and elevated, the opposite occurs. This misguided concept allows for moments of religious ecstasy and yet the whole of life is left out of the religious experience. This invites the most decadent elements of human nature to develop. GS)

Beraishis 2:7, Pages 56-57

Share

Beraishis 2F וייצר- ב יצירות – The Dual Nature of Man

The word the Torah uses to say that God formed Man is וייצר, the letter “yud” appearing twice. As the word יצר can mean inclination or formation, our sages teach us that this verse contains a number of related lessons.

– Man is both mortal and immortal
– Man is both earthly and heavenly
– Man has a good inclination and a bad inclination

When this word is pronounced only one “yud” is heard. Man always appears to have both sides of him but one side is always the more dominant. Which one is up to him. The most holy person is still a person. In the background is his body and his inclinations. He had to fight to be as holy as he is. And even a person who seems to be at the lowest rung of his humanity still contains a spark of holiness within him.

Both inclinations and aspects of Man were created from the very beginning. The God who created Man’s inclination toward the spirit, created Man’s earthly inclinations. There is nothing unholy or wrong with either of Man’s inclinations as long as they are put to use according to God’s instructions. Man was not created to be a מלאך. Man is not pure white. That is God’s realm. That is the realm of angels. Man was created to be אדם. Man is put on earth. whose spiritual side is broken up by his encounter with the physical. Man is “red”. (See this very fundamental concept that RSRH refers to often.)

In this world, the world of the senses and with his sensuous nature, Man is to live his life and uplift it all in the service of God. The Christian concept that the sensuous nature of Man comes from Satan is a twisted concept that has been the curse of Man throughout history. (I believe RSRH is saying that by rejecting the body as a part of the service to God, Christianity has missed the main intention of Man’s mission; to uplift his body and this world. By striving to relegate the body as something evil, the body remains unholy or worse. The world does not become transformed and elevated, the opposite occurs. This misguided concept allows for moments of religious ecstasy and yet the whole of life is left out of the religious experience. This invites the most decadent elements of human nature to develop. GS)

Beraishis 2:7, Pages 56-57

Share

Suffering and the Bigger Picture

After all the parts of creation were in place, God looked at it all – כל- and said it was very good.

The word כל in its deeper sense means the purpose behind a totality of (seemingly disconnected and even contradictory)  parts.

From a superficial perspective, the world seems imperfect. There is much suffering and hardship. True good, however, “very good”, is that which fosters spiritual and moral growth. Sometimes this may not be immediately apparent in this world. Everything in this world is for a higher purpose. We are in this world moving towards the next world. Looking at it “all”, it is very good.

This is the meaning behind the Midrash Rabbah on this verse which states that the words “very good” were referring to suffering, death and the evil inclination! All of these, despite the hardship and difficulties they create, enable Man to climb higher and grow closer to God. They must exist.

The totality of God’s creation is very good.

Beraishis 1:31, Pages 38-39

See Letter 6 of The Nineteen Letters on History

See Letter 9 of The Nineteen Letters on Exile

Share

Beraishis 1R Suffering and the Bigger Picture

After all the parts of creation were in place, God looked at it all – כל- and said it was very good.

The word כל in its deeper sense means the purpose behind a totality of (seemingly disconnected and even contradictory)  parts.

From a superficial perspective, the world seems imperfect. There is much suffering and hardship. True good, however, “very good”, is that which fosters spiritual and moral growth. Sometimes this may not be immediately apparent in this world. Everything in this world is for a higher purpose. We are in this world moving towards the next world. Looking at it “all”, it is very good.

This is the meaning behind the Midrash Rabbah on this verse which states that the words “very good” were referring to suffering, death and the evil inclination! All of these, despite the hardship and difficulties they create, enable Man to climb higher and grow closer to God. They must exist.

The totality of God’s creation is very good.

Beraishis 1:31, Pages 38-39

Share